Breville Barista Express vs Gaggia Classic Pro
Breville's all-in-one with a built-in grinder, or a Gaggia that needs its own. Whether you already own a grinder decides which used one to buy.
Side by side
How to choose
The Barista Express is a full kit in one box, grinder included. The Classic Pro is a simpler espresso machine that needs a grinder beside it. Used, both are everywhere, so it comes down to two things. Do you already own a grinder, and how much do you want to tinker?
Breville Barista Express
Breville, the Australian appliance company founded in 1932, sells this as the BES870 in the US. It heats with a thermocoil under PID control. It has a 54mm stainless portafilter, low-pressure pre-infusion, a 67 oz reservoir at the back and a conical burr grinder built in, with 16 grind settings and an 8 oz bean hopper. It ships with dual-wall baskets, which forgive an uneven grind or tamp, and single-wall baskets for when you get better. The steam wand has a single hole, and the body is 12.5 inches wide. Breville has since added the Barista Express Impress, so don't confuse the two in listings.
Gaggia Classic Pro
Gaggia has sold the Classic since 1991. The Classic Pro arrived in 2019 and the current Pro E24 moved from an aluminum boiler to brass. The E24 has a 58mm stainless portafilter, a 15 bar pump with a 9 bar OPV, a 3-way solenoid valve and a two-hole commercial-style steam wand, in a body 8 inches wide. It has no grinder, and it needs one that can grind fine and adjust in small steps for espresso.
The real trade-off
The Express saves you buying a grinder, and the dual-wall baskets make your first week easier. But the grinder and the machine share one body. If the grinder wears out, you're stuck with it or you buy a separate one anyway. The Classic Pro's 58mm group takes standard tampers, baskets and bottomless portafilters, and it's a simpler machine to open up and repair. Pair it with a good grinder and you'll have more room to improve.
Testing each one from a listing
For an Express, ask for a video of the grinder running at a fine setting and a shot pulled with the single-wall basket. Coffee should start dripping after a few seconds and flow as a steady stream, and the pressure gauge should sit in the espresso range. Check that the hopper, the tamper and both basket types are in the photos, or take their cost off the price you'll accept. For a Gaggia, find out whether it's an E24, and ask for the descaling history if it isn't.
Our call
If you don't own a grinder and want one purchase, buy the Express. If you already have an espresso grinder, or plan to buy one, get the Classic Pro.

